Where To Host a Murder Mystery Party? 7 Creative Venue Ideas!

Murder mystery parties are a fantastic way to engage friends, family, or colleagues in an evening of suspense, intrigue, and fun. One of the first steps to planning your party is picking an appropriate setting. The setting can significantly enhance your experience, making your event more memorable!  If you're wondering where to host your next murder mystery party, here are some various and creative ideas to consider.

1. At Your House or Apartment

Pros: Hosting a murder mystery party at your home is convenient and cost-effective. You have complete control over the environment and can tailor the décor to fit the theme of your mystery. Whether you opt for a cozy dinner party in your living room or a full-scale event using multiple rooms, your home offers flexibility. As long as you have a little space for guests to have private conversations, any house or apartment will work!

Cons: Limited space might be an issue if you have a large guest list. Additionally, hosting at home requires you to prep and clean up ahead of time. 

Tips: Use lighting, on-theme soundtracks, and setting appropriate props to create an immersive atmosphere. Transform your space with thematic decorations using ideas from our Pinterest. 

A murder mystery party hosted in an apartment

2. Host Online on Zoom, Discord, or Gather

Pros: Virtual platforms like Zoom, Discord, and Gather all make it possible to host fun murder mystery parties even when guests are scattered across different locations. These platforms offer various interactive features that can add to the experience and make it feel like you are mixing and mingling in a physical space. 

Cons: Hosting an event online requires a little tech knowledge and savviness to set up the event. You also need to be comfortable helping answer questions with tech and troubleshooting, such as helping folks log on, sending around files, and preparing materials. We have lots of resources to help first-time hosts set up online! 

Tips: Use breakout rooms for private discussions and clues. Customize your virtual background to fit the theme, and encourage guests to dress up to add to the ambiance. Gather offers a more interactive environment where participants can move around a virtual space, which can make the game feel more dynamic.

A murder mystery party hosted over Discord!

3. Outside: Backyard or Camping

Pros: Hosting your party outdoors adds a unique twist. A backyard provides ample space, fresh air, and natural lighting, while a camp setting can elevate the mystery with the added thrill of the great outdoors.

Cons: Weather conditions can be unpredictable, and outdoor locations may require additional logistical planning for seating, lighting, and sound.

Tips: For backyard parties, use string lights, fire pits, and outdoor speakers to set the mood. In a camp setting, consider a nighttime scenario with flashlights, tents, and campfire storytelling to create a spine-chilling atmosphere. You can even theme the food around the setting or host a BBQ. 

Foulplayers hosting our ‘80s summer camp murder mystery party, Cabin #5, outdoors!

4. Renting a Cool Airbnb or VRBO

Pros: Renting a unique property on platforms like Airbnb or VRBO can provide a fantastic backdrop for your murder mystery party. From rustic cabins to luxurious mansions, the right rental can add an extra layer of excitement and realism to your event.

Cons: This option can be more expensive and requires advanced booking and coordination. You also need to ensure the property owner allows such events.

Tips: Choose a property that matches the theme of your mystery. A Victorian-style home is perfect for a classic whodunit, while a cabin is perfect for an ‘80s horror. Make sure to communicate with your guests about any specific logistics related to the rental property.

Hosting our true crime murder mystery party, The Wych Elm, in an AirBnB rental!

5. Local Community Centers, Libraries, or Event Spaces

Pros: Community centers, libraries, or local event spaces can usually accommodate larger groups and often come with facilities like kitchens, restrooms, and parking. These spaces can be ideal for more elaborate setups and themes!

Cons: Renting an event space can be costly and availability may be limited. You'll also need to transport and set up all your decorations and props.

Tips: Check if the venue offers additional services like catering, decorations, or audio-visual equipment that can add to the party. Ensure you have enough time for setup and teardown within your rental period.

6. Unique Locations: Museums, Historic Sites, or Themed Restaurants

Pros: Hosting your party in a unique location like a museum, historic site, or themed restaurant can provide an unforgettable experience. These venues often have a unique ambiance of their own that can complement your storyline or theme.

Cons: These locations can be expensive and may have restrictions on decorations and activities. Availability may also be limited to certain dates and times.

Tips: Coordinate closely with the venue staff to understand the possibilities and limitations. Incorporate the venue's history or features into your mystery plot to make the experience more immersive!

7. At the Workplace

Pros: Hosting a murder mystery party at the workplace can be an excellent team-building activity. It encourages colleagues to interact in a fun and engaging way outside of their usual work responsibilities. Utilizing office space can be convenient and cost-effective, especially if you have access to meeting rooms or common areas.

Cons: The professional environment may make it difficult for some participants to fully relax and immerse themselves in the game. Additionally, there may be limitations on how much you can decorate or rearrange the space.

Tips:

Choose a theme that is appropriate and enjoyable for all employees. Plan the event during an appropriate time, such as a Friday afternoon or as part of a scheduled team-building day, to ensure maximum participation and enjoyment without interfering with work.

Choosing the right location for your murder mystery party depends on your budget, guest list, and the type of experience you want to create. Whether you opt for the comfort of your home, the convenience of online platforms, the charm of an outdoor setting, the allure of a rented property, or a specialized venue, the key is to plan carefully and pay attention to details. With the right setting, your murder mystery party will be a thrilling success that your guests will remember for many years to come!